EU Divided Over Proposals for Client-Side Scanning to Combat Online Child Exploitation
Denmark’s proposal for client-side scanning of encrypted services has reignited a contentious debate within the European Union regarding measures to combat online child exploitation. Advocates argue that this method allows the scanning of images without compromising encryption, while privacy advocates strongly disagree, citing potential violations of civil liberties, reports 24brussels.
The EU member states are divided into two primary factions. One group supports the measures as essential for preventing the distribution of illegal content involving children, while the opposing faction warns that such initiatives could lead to a surveillance state and question their efficacy.
Germany has been one of the most vocal critics of these scanning measures, although recent developments indicate wavering certainty among its officials. Other significant opponents include Poland, which, during its presidency of the EU Council, advocated for maintaining scanning as a voluntary process rather than mandating it for end-to-end encrypted services.
In contrast, countries like Denmark and Sweden, which have seen rising concerns over children’s safety on social media, support more stringent measures. Additionally, Spain has expressed reluctance toward encryption, while France aligns with Denmark in backing the proposal.
Within national governments, departments often display conflicting perspectives. Interior ministries, tasked with policing and security, generally favor tougher measures to apprehend offenders, while justice and digital ministries emphasize protecting civil liberties and enhancing cybersecurity.
In Germany, the justice minister recently expressed firm opposition to Denmark’s initiative, but the ultimate responsibility lies with the Interior Ministry, which tends to advocate for more robust policing measures.
At the EU level, agencies like Europol and the European Commission’s home affairs ministry have vigorously promoted new policies aimed at expanding law enforcement’s access to data. Controversially, the Commission has previously been found to have conducted campaigns that unlawfully targeted individuals in support of the child sexual abuse material (CSAM) legislation.
FEATURED_IMAGE_URL: https://www.politico.eu/cdn-cgi/image/width=1200,height=630,fit=crop,quality=80,onerror=redirect/wp-content/uploads/2025/10/10/GettyImages-2203175651-scaled.jpg
